I think that, in theory, it would make sense to create multiple, more specific, topics and trying to stay on topic. In practice, I don’t know if we are interested enough to do it, especially considering that some people will just avoid the whole forum to avoid spoilers.
I am trying to figure out if it is possible to find a combination of different sites/services that will allow me to both enjoy the game and chat about non-gameplay topics in a spoiler-free way.
That already exists and I tried it, but at least the first version wasn’t very good in my opinion. Now they have expanded it into a “create your own text adventure game”, but I’ve not tried it:
Maybe you have become a ghost and you have to find a way to seek revenge from the afterlife.
I’ve not tried this new version because it seems that the developers have complicated the interface a lot. The previous version used a simple text area. For its simplicity, it wasn’t bad.
Sometime I don’t understand people talking about UI issues.