“Posts” would be more correct. For example some critics were mentioned here.
To sum up all posts I’ve read about MI4, there seems to be the following negative arguments (in this order):
- The controls are horrible.
- The graphics are ugly.
- The puzzles were bad.
- The story is weak.
Same here. I remember more parts in MI3 than things from MI4 - and I played all MI games in chronological order. I don’t remember anything from the story and only very few puzzles. So they can’t be that “impressive”.
In MI4 I don’t like the controls and the graphics. But this is maybe due to the fact, that I’ve played MI1, MI2 and MI3 first. So Monkey Island is connected in my brain with hand-drawn comic graphics. 