I actually heard some Americans claim that the British originally spoke with an accent that’s way more similar to today’s American accent, and then started “faking” it on purpose after US independence to separate them, and this led to current British accents.
I think this is idiotic and false, but hey, in this world view that means that an American voice actor would be the best person to voice a pre-1776 Brit
Yeah people love the idea that the Appalachian accent or the Southern accent is somehow a frozen-in-time Colonial English accent. It’s like clickbait headlines, if it’s absolutely absurd and has a grain of truth, people love to believe it.
The only American accents that would be more hilarious to make this claim with are our Surfer or Fargo accents. So I expect these claims to be made soon and catch on like wildfire.
That’s incredibly interesting for me. Where can I learn more about how the British accent has evolved over time?
I don’t want to derail this thread too much off topic, though. If you could just mention a few links/books/resources to study, I would really appreciate it.
I remember I read something, about this old world nod.
Anyway, it makes perfectly sense. I might be wrong, but -historicallly speaking- it is quite unlikely he came from the States. I bet all the adventurers coming in the Caribbean in 1600 were from England, France, Spain. Holland, at most.
Anyway I gave it for granted he was British.
Well, the fact that Guybrush is British seemed pretty obvious to ME doesn’t mean that it was for anybody. Since his mother country isn’t essential for the plot, my guess is simply that the casting director of CMI (when Dominic Armato was hired, and Ron Gilbert no longer had a say in the matter) didn’t bother to ask himself if Guybrush could have been “stranger”.
But I like to think, a posteriori, that an american accent is coherent: Guybrush, the mighty pirate who lived straddling XVII and XVIII century, is British. But Guybrush, the kid who impersonated him while playing with his brother, seems to be a XIX century rural american boy, with some old-fashioned parents.
AFAIR, Otis says the flowers are called “caniche endormi”, but…
…I didn’t remember Guybrush gave it away like this!